Comparison

CMP vs runtime consent scanner

Consent platforms help configure and present choices. Runtime scanning helps verify what actually happens in the browser before and after those choices.

Run a free website behavior scan

Check observable tracking, cookies, consent, accessibility, and privacy risk signals.

Run a scan

Direct answer

A CMP manages consent choices, preferences, categories, and banner presentation. A runtime consent scanner observes browser behavior and can surface whether tracking or cookies appear before or after those choices.

The two tools are complementary. CertScore.ai does not replace a CMP; it helps teams review observable behavior around the CMP.

Where a CMP helps

CMPs help configure notices, consent categories, regional rules, preference centers, and consent signals for downstream tags.

They are the operational control plane for collecting and storing choices.

Where runtime scanning helps

Runtime scanning can surface request timing, cookie timing, vendor domains, and whether observed behavior appears to change after consent interactions.

This evidence helps teams investigate implementation drift without making legal conclusions.

Sample JSON

Sample finding JSON from scans

Representative payloads from retained scan examples for the finding types discussed on this page.

Third-party tracking observed before recorded consent

pre_consent_tracking_detected

Illustrative public evidence sample

{
  "example_type": "positive",
  "domain": "example.com",
  "requested_url": "https://example.com/",
  "final_url": "https://example.com/",
  "created_at": "2026-05-18T18:20:10.442Z",
  "scanned_at": "2026-05-18T18:20:18.912Z",
  "finding_id": "pre_consent_tracking_detected",
  "finding_label": "Third-party tracking observed before recorded consent",
  "section": "Privacy & Tracking",
  "evidenceConfidence": "strong",
  "directVsInferred": "direct_observation",
  "evidence": {
    "counts": {
      "firstRequestMs": 1137,
      "firstThirdPartyRequestMs": 3405,
      "firstCookieSeenMs": 3468,
      "total_cookie_count": 3,
      "total_vendor_count": 2,
      "total_request_count": 12,
      "total_tracker_count": 1,
      "third_party_cookie_count": 0,
      "third_party_request_count": 2,
      "preConsentTrackingRequestCount": 1,
      "preConsentTrackingSignalCount": 2
    },
    "evidence_snippets": [
      "Example Tag Manager",
      "Example Analytics",
      "tagmanager.example",
      "analytics.example",
      "script_host:tagmanager.example",
      "request:https://analytics.example/g/collect [query_redacted=true]",
      "cookie:_ga [value_redacted=true]"
    ],
    "vendors": [
      "Example Tag Manager",
      "Example Analytics"
    ],
    "request_domains": [
      "tagmanager.example",
      "analytics.example"
    ],
    "request_samples": [
      {
        "artifactRef": "req_001",
        "role": "supporting_context_only",
        "origin": "https://tagmanager.example",
        "path": "/gtm.js",
        "queryRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 1137
      },
      {
        "artifactRef": "req_002",
        "role": "finding_supporting_artifact",
        "origin": "https://analytics.example",
        "path": "/g/collect",
        "queryRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 3405,
        "essentiality": "non_essential",
        "purposeCategory": "analytics_measurement"
      }
    ],
    "cookie_samples": [
      {
        "artifactRef": "storage_001",
        "role": "finding_supporting_artifact",
        "name": "_ga",
        "valueRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 3468,
        "essentiality": "non_essential",
        "purposeCategory": "analytics_identifier"
      }
    ],
    "consent_summary": {
      "cmp_vendor": "Example CMP",
      "preconsent_tracking_detected": true,
      "banner_present": true,
      "consent_state_observed": "no_choice_observed",
      "consent_action_observed_before_first_signal": false,
      "observed_prior_consent_state_for_purpose": false
    },
    "fingerprinting_or_device_signals": {
      "fingerprinting_vendor_detected": false,
      "device_signal_vendor_detected": null
    },
    "runtime_anchors": [
      "req_002:https://analytics.example/g/collect [query_redacted=true]",
      "storage_001:_ga [value_redacted=true]"
    ]
  },
  "coverage_flags": [],
  "known_limitations": [
    "Illustrative public sample with redacted query strings and cookie values.",
    "Review consent state, vendor purpose, regional configuration, and exemptions before taking action."
  ],
  "selection_reason": "Illustrative public sample with consent timeline, classified non-essential runtime anchors, and usable coverage.",
  "evidenceVersion": "2.0",
  "scanContext": {
    "domain": "example.com",
    "requestedUrl": "https://example.com/",
    "finalUrl": "https://example.com/",
    "publicWebObservation": true,
    "legalConclusion": false
  },
  "artifacts": {
    "runtimeAnchors": [
      "req_002:https://analytics.example/g/collect [query_redacted=true]",
      "storage_001:_ga [value_redacted=true]"
    ],
    "requestSamples": [
      {
        "artifactRef": "req_001",
        "role": "supporting_context_only",
        "origin": "https://tagmanager.example",
        "path": "/gtm.js",
        "queryRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 1137
      },
      {
        "artifactRef": "req_002",
        "role": "finding_supporting_artifact",
        "origin": "https://analytics.example",
        "path": "/g/collect",
        "queryRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 3405,
        "essentiality": "non_essential",
        "purposeCategory": "analytics_measurement"
      }
    ],
    "cookieOrStorageSamples": [
      {
        "artifactRef": "storage_001",
        "role": "finding_supporting_artifact",
        "name": "_ga",
        "valueRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 3468,
        "essentiality": "non_essential",
        "purposeCategory": "analytics_identifier"
      }
    ],
    "policyAnchors": [],
    "rawValuesRetained": false
  },
  "classification": {
    "section": "Privacy & Tracking",
    "criticality": "review",
    "evidenceConfidence": "strong",
    "directVsInferred": "direct_observation",
    "legalStatusDetermined": false
  },
  "coverage": {
    "coverageFlags": [],
    "coverageReliableForTopRanking": true,
    "notDetectedMeans": "not_observed_in_scan_scope",
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  },
  "topFindingCalibration": {
    "minimumToSurface": [
      "Classified non-essential request/storage before observed consent."
    ],
    "highConfidenceRequires": [
      "Usable coverage.",
      "Purpose classification.",
      "Runtime anchor."
    ],
    "criticalOrTopRankingRequires": [
      "Advertising/replay/identifier-sync or sensitive-surface context."
    ],
    "demoteOrSuppressWhen": [
      "Tag manager only.",
      "Strict necessity.",
      "Blocked scan.",
      "Unreliable timing."
    ]
  },
  "automationLimits": [
    "Automated public-web observations do not determine legal status, compliance status, proof that a law was breached, proof of data capture, or tracking lawfulness.",
    "Manual review is needed to confirm purpose, necessity, jurisdiction, configuration, exemptions, and remediation quality."
  ],
  "redaction": {
    "rawIdentifiersRetained": false,
    "storageValueContentsRetained": false,
    "completeQueryStringsRetained": false,
    "requestBodiesRetained": false,
    "renderedPageImagesRetained": false,
    "sourceMarkupRetained": false,
    "userEnteredValuesRetained": false
  },
  "selectionReason": "Illustrative public sample with consent timeline, classified non-essential runtime anchors, and usable coverage.",
  "consentTimeline": {
    "firstRequestMs": 1137,
    "firstThirdPartyRequestMs": 3405,
    "firstCookieSeenMs": 3468,
    "consentActionObservedBeforeFirstSignal": false,
    "consentStateBasis": "observed_scan_scope",
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  },
  "networkEvidence": {
    "artifactRefs": [
      {
        "artifactRef": "req_001",
        "role": "supporting_context_only",
        "origin": "https://tagmanager.example",
        "path": "/gtm.js",
        "queryRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 1137
      },
      {
        "artifactRef": "req_002",
        "role": "finding_supporting_artifact",
        "origin": "https://analytics.example",
        "path": "/g/collect",
        "queryRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 3405,
        "essentiality": "non_essential",
        "purposeCategory": "analytics_measurement"
      }
    ],
    "cookieOrStorageArtifacts": [
      {
        "artifactRef": "storage_001",
        "role": "finding_supporting_artifact",
        "name": "_ga",
        "valueRedacted": true,
        "timestampMs": 3468,
        "essentiality": "non_essential",
        "purposeCategory": "analytics_identifier"
      }
    ],
    "vendorCategory": "Example Tag Manager",
    "queryStringsRedacted": true,
    "valuesRedacted": true,
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  }
}

Non-essential tracking continued after reject

reject_tracking_persists_after_reject

Illustrative public evidence sample

{
  "finding_id": "reject_tracking_persists_after_reject",
  "finding_label": "Non-essential tracking continued after reject",
  "category": "Consent / tracking",
  "criticality": "high",
  "evidenceConfidence": "good",
  "directVsInferred": "direct_observation",
  "observed": "Retained runtime evidence showed a reject-style consent interaction followed by classified non-essential request or storage activity in the observed scan scope.",
  "evidence": {
    "summary": "Retained runtime evidence showed a reject-style consent interaction followed by classified non-essential request or storage activity in the observed scan scope.",
    "examples": [
      {
        "title": "Post-reject runtime artifact",
        "lines": [
          "artifact=req_002",
          "role=finding_supporting_artifact",
          "url=https://example.com/",
          "reject_action_timestamp_ms=2600",
          "reject_action_observed=true",
          "post_reject_request_timestamp_ms=4120",
          "request_origin=https://analytics.example",
          "request_path=/collect [query_redacted=true]",
          "vendor_category=analytics",
          "essentiality=non_essential",
          "review_caveat=manual review should confirm reject success, queued-beacon timing, purpose, necessity, and CMP/vendor configuration"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "automationLimits": [
      "Automated evidence may not fully determine reject success, queued beacons, vendor responsibility, consent validity, or legal status.",
      "Manual review is needed to confirm timing, purpose, CMP propagation, and remediation quality."
    ]
  },
  "evidenceVersion": "2.0",
  "scanContext": {
    "domain": "example.com",
    "requestedUrl": "https://example.com/",
    "finalUrl": "https://example.com/",
    "publicWebObservation": true,
    "legalConclusion": false
  },
  "artifacts": {
    "runtimeAnchors": [],
    "requestSamples": [],
    "cookieOrStorageSamples": [],
    "policyAnchors": [],
    "rawValuesRetained": false
  },
  "classification": {
    "section": "Review signal",
    "criticality": "high",
    "evidenceConfidence": "good",
    "directVsInferred": "direct_observation",
    "legalStatusDetermined": false
  },
  "coverage": {
    "coverageFlags": [],
    "coverageReliableForTopRanking": true,
    "notDetectedMeans": "not_observed_in_scan_scope",
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  },
  "topFindingCalibration": {
    "minimumToSurface": [
      "Reject interaction plus post-reject classified non-essential request/storage."
    ],
    "highConfidenceRequires": [
      "Reject success.",
      "Pre/post sequence.",
      "Artifact classification."
    ],
    "criticalOrTopRankingRequires": [
      "Post-reject advertising/replay/identifier sync or repeated post-reject artifacts."
    ],
    "demoteOrSuppressWhen": [
      "Reject button present but not clicked.",
      "Unknown essentiality.",
      "Queued pre-reject beacon likely."
    ]
  },
  "automationLimits": [
    "Automated public-web observations do not determine legal status, compliance status, proof that a law was breached, proof of data capture, or tracking lawfulness.",
    "Manual review is needed to confirm purpose, necessity, jurisdiction, configuration, exemptions, and remediation quality."
  ],
  "redaction": {
    "rawIdentifiersRetained": false,
    "storageValueContentsRetained": false,
    "completeQueryStringsRetained": false,
    "requestBodiesRetained": false,
    "renderedPageImagesRetained": false,
    "sourceMarkupRetained": false,
    "userEnteredValuesRetained": false
  },
  "selectionReason": "Illustrative public sample selected to show retained evidence, directness, limits, and top-finding calibration.",
  "consentTimeline": {
    "firstRequestMs": null,
    "firstThirdPartyRequestMs": null,
    "firstCookieSeenMs": null,
    "consentActionObservedBeforeFirstSignal": false,
    "consentStateBasis": "observed_scan_scope",
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  },
  "networkEvidence": {
    "artifactRefs": [],
    "cookieOrStorageArtifacts": [],
    "vendorCategory": "manual_review_recommended",
    "queryStringsRedacted": true,
    "valuesRedacted": true,
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  }
}

Third-party cookie or storage observed before consent

third_party_cookie_pre_consent

Illustrative public evidence sample

{
  "finding_id": "third_party_cookie_pre_consent",
  "finding_label": "Third-party cookie or storage observed before consent",
  "category": "Cookies",
  "criticality": "high",
  "evidenceConfidence": "review_signal",
  "directVsInferred": "direct_observation",
  "observed": "Retained runtime evidence showed a third-party cookie or storage artifact observed before CertScore recorded a consent action or a prior consent state associated with that purpose.",
  "evidence": {
    "summary": "Retained runtime evidence showed a third-party cookie or storage artifact observed before CertScore recorded a consent action or a prior consent state associated with that purpose.",
    "examples": [
      {
        "title": "Third-party cookie timing example",
        "lines": [
          "artifact=storage_001",
          "role=finding_supporting_artifact",
          "url=https://example.com/",
          "type=cookie_observed",
          "cookie_name=example_id",
          "value_redacted=true",
          "cookie_domain=.ads.example",
          "cookie_scope=third_party",
          "first_seen_ms=1840",
          "consent_action_observed_before_first_seen=false",
          "prior_consent_state_for_purpose=false",
          "purpose_category=advertising_or_measurement [manual_review_recommended]"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "automationLimits": [
      "Automated storage evidence may not determine purpose, necessity, exemption status, or legal status.",
      "Manual review is needed to confirm cookie purpose, consent state, regional configuration, and remediation quality."
    ]
  },
  "evidenceVersion": "2.0",
  "scanContext": {
    "domain": "example.com",
    "requestedUrl": "https://example.com/",
    "finalUrl": "https://example.com/",
    "publicWebObservation": true,
    "legalConclusion": false
  },
  "artifacts": {
    "runtimeAnchors": [],
    "requestSamples": [],
    "cookieOrStorageSamples": [],
    "policyAnchors": [],
    "rawValuesRetained": false
  },
  "classification": {
    "section": "Review signal",
    "criticality": "high",
    "evidenceConfidence": "review_signal",
    "directVsInferred": "direct_observation",
    "legalStatusDetermined": false
  },
  "coverage": {
    "coverageFlags": [],
    "coverageReliableForTopRanking": true,
    "notDetectedMeans": "not_observed_in_scan_scope",
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  },
  "topFindingCalibration": {
    "minimumToSurface": [
      "Third-party cookie/storage artifact before consent."
    ],
    "highConfidenceRequires": [
      "Domain/scope/timing plus purpose or vendor classification."
    ],
    "criticalOrTopRankingRequires": [
      "Advertising/identity/sync persistent storage or repeated pages."
    ],
    "demoteOrSuppressWhen": [
      "Request only.",
      "Cookie name only.",
      "Unknown timing.",
      "Blocked scan."
    ]
  },
  "automationLimits": [
    "Automated public-web observations do not determine legal status, compliance status, proof that a law was breached, proof of data capture, or tracking lawfulness.",
    "Manual review is needed to confirm purpose, necessity, jurisdiction, configuration, exemptions, and remediation quality."
  ],
  "redaction": {
    "rawIdentifiersRetained": false,
    "storageValueContentsRetained": false,
    "completeQueryStringsRetained": false,
    "requestBodiesRetained": false,
    "renderedPageImagesRetained": false,
    "sourceMarkupRetained": false,
    "userEnteredValuesRetained": false
  },
  "selectionReason": "Illustrative public sample selected to show retained evidence, directness, limits, and top-finding calibration.",
  "consentTimeline": {
    "firstRequestMs": null,
    "firstThirdPartyRequestMs": null,
    "firstCookieSeenMs": null,
    "consentActionObservedBeforeFirstSignal": false,
    "consentStateBasis": "observed_scan_scope",
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  },
  "networkEvidence": {
    "artifactRefs": [],
    "cookieOrStorageArtifacts": [],
    "vendorCategory": "manual_review_recommended",
    "queryStringsRedacted": true,
    "valuesRedacted": true,
    "manualReviewNeeded": true
  }
}

Summary for AI assistants

CMP vs runtime consent scanner explains an observable public website review topic in CertScore.ai's evidence-backed scanning workflow.

CertScore.ai observes public website behavior around tracking, cookies, consent behavior, session replay indicators, fingerprinting-related signals, accessibility, and privacy disclosures. CertScore findings are automated risk signals for review and are not legal advice, certification, or compliance determinations.

Related CertScore pages

CMP verification guide Consent enforcement checker Cookiebot runtime testing OneTrust runtime testing

Run a free website behavior scan

Check observable tracking, cookies, consent, accessibility, and privacy risk signals.

Run a scan

CertScore.ai automated findings may contain errors. Always review the underlying evidence. CertScore.ai does not provide legal advice, certification, or compliance determinations.